Tessa, the Lizard Hunter

GOLDEN GAZETTE - By Lorilynn Bowles

Every Golden Retriever seems to have a special talent.  Our Rudy is a champion Speed Digger.  He can move buckets of earth in seconds.  Millie is a Nylabone Inventory Control Specialist.  She gathers all the Nylabones, and only the Nylabones, into a pile.  She may pick one to chew, but quite often she merely contemplates their numbers.  Tessa is clever at a number of things, but her most surprising skill, honed over years of practice, is Lizard Hunting.
To successfully capture a lizard takes strategy and stealth -- not two traits normally attributed to Golden Retrievers.  Tessa’s big strength is that she is “doggedly” determined.  When she puts her mind to something, she usually succeeds.  Tess came to live with us when she was five. She had been a breeder in a puppy mill and no longer a profitable commodity.  Fortunately, the Rescue saved her.  She had never known the pleasure of a large backyard and took to it like a fish to water.  Fearless, feisty and curious, she spent hours exploring every nook and cranny.  She first sighted one of the common garden lizards sunning itself on a block wall.  Full speed, she raced to investigate.  The lizard, seeing her approach, shot over the wall. That moment set her on a mission more unlikely than King Arthur’s quest of the Holy Grail. Tessa was determined to catch a lizard!
Thus started years of one of the most dedicated, self-training programs ever set upon.  Tessa worked out fairly quickly that charging like a wild bull got her nowhere.  She advanced to the slow sneak-up -- practicing this for months, with no results.  Finally, Tessa progressed to what can only be called Retriever Ninja.  With Zen-like concentration, she would focus on a lizard standing motionless for minutes at a time. Slowly, ever so slowly, she would raise a paw; then, with perfect balance, lower it as slowly again, just inches forward.  It was both beautiful and a little terrifying to watch -- like one of those nature programs where the leopard is stalking its prey.  Quite mesmerizing, but you’re not sure you want to see the outcome.  She’d get within a couple of feet, but the lizard, perhaps feeling Tessa’s breath, would bolt.

2007 Tainted Pet Food - Melamine - Recall Update

Share:

 

Pet owners receive $12.4 million in melamine case

October 12, 2011
By: Edie Lau
For The VIN News Service

Like most pet owners affected by the melamine contamination and pet food recall of 2007, Karl Rahder was reimbursed for about half of his claimed expenses under a $24 million class-action court settlement. His cat, Inca, survived, but never regained full vigor. Photo courtesy of Karl Rahder.

Owners of animals affected by food contaminated with melamine received slightly more than half of the money in a $24-million fund established to settle legal claims stemming from the largest pet food recall in North America.

The balance of the fund went to lawyers’ fees and expenses, claims administration and public notices.

In all, $12,357,277 was paid on 20,229 claims from the United States and Canada, according to information provided by the claims administrator, the accounting firm Heffler, Radetich & Saitta LLP in Philadelphia.

A total of $27,793,975.36 in claims was judged eligible for compensation. However, the collective payout was significantly less — amounting to 45 cents on the dollar. The claims administrator cited several factors for the reductions: Some claims had been reimbursed before the court action. Some exceeded the $900 limit for undocumented damages. Most significantly, most were reduced pro rata because the fund was not big enough to pay all approved claims in full.

The claims concerned pets that ate cat and dog food tainted with melamine and cyanuric acid. Unscrupulous suppliers in China added the contaminants in trying to inflate the apparent protein levels in wheat gluten and rice protein concentrate. The adulterated ingredients ended up in foods and treats made by 12 different manufacturers, according to court documents.

Discovery of the contamination led in 2007 to the biggest pet food recall in history, involving about 180 brands and some of the most prominent names in the business — Hill’s Pet Nutrition, Mars Inc., Del Monte Pet Products, Nestle Purina PetCare Co., The Iams Co. and Procter & Gamble among them — as well as dozens of retailers, including Wal-Mart, Target, PetSmart, Petco and Costco. The majority of products came from Menu Foods, a Canadian company contracted to manufacture numerous brand-name and private label pet foods.

Tens of thousands of animals ate the poisoned foods, and many became sick, some fatally. The combination of melamine and cyanuric acid forms crystals in the kidneys, potentially leading to renal disease and renal failure.

The scandal led to the criminal prosecution of the American company ChemNutra, Inc., and its owners for their role in importing the tainted ingredients. They pleaded guilty last year to distributing adulterated food and selling misbranded food, both misdemeanors.

On the civil-court side, more than 100 class-action suits arose out of the incident. Those cases were consolidated and addressed by the $24 million settlement. Although court documents and related information are available online, information on how the fund was distributed is not posted publicly.

That’s not unusual, according to Timothy Eble, a class-action expert in South Carolina who was not involved in the pet food case. “Typically the manner in which payments generally will be calculated is available through the court but the amounts actually to be disbursed to any individual would not necessarily be available,” he said.

The VIN News Service obtained details on how settlement funds were disbursed by contacting Russell Paul of Berger & Montague, P.C., of Philadelphia, co-lead counsel for the plaintiffs. Paul, in turn, requested the information from the claims administrator.

Click here for larger view

Several claimants emailed the VIN News Service to express disappointment with the size of their shares of the settlement. Paul said he, too, has heard from a number of chagrined pet owners. “People want all of their money,” Paul acknowledged.

Count Elise Maitland of Victoria Harbor, Ontario, among the dismayed. Maitland lost her collie-Labrador mix Michigan to kidney failure after he ate tainted Ol’ Roy canned food with gravy. “The $500 I received did not even pay the vet bill, let alone a new pet,” she fumed. “...I feel we were extremely ripped off.”

Asked if, in retrospect, he thought that the settlement fund was inadequate, Paul replied, “We pushed and pushed and pushed, and feel we got the maximum we could get.”

Paul described the case as extremely complicated. The litigation involved more than 80 lawyers for plaintiffs in two countries, more than two dozen defendants and several appeals that stalled the payout.

“It was three to four years of bitter fighting, from District Court up to the 3rd Circuit (Court of Appeals) and back to the District Court,” Paul said.

Evaluation of claims likewise was complex, he noted. “Each one had to be individually analyzed, and often veterinarians had to be called,” Paul said. “The possibility was rife for fraud.”

Sherrie Savett, who served as co-lead counsel with Paul, added that even the public-communications aspect of the settlement wasn’t simple, involving the placement of notices in multiple periodicals in two countries, and creation and maintenance of the website.

Paul said the fact that plaintiffs did not receive 100 percent of their damages is not unusual in class-action suits.

Eble concurred. “If they got half of their actual damages, that’s actually a pretty good result in a class action,” said Eble, who operates a website intended as a neutral source of information for the public about class-action issues.

“What you’re talking about with 20,000 people, most would have claims that vary from $200 to $3,000, depending on what the specific facts were,” he explained. “They (individually) would not have been able to hire a lawyer to go through discovery and pursue the case for less than the value of the claim.”

Paul said he understands how deeply the contamination afflicted pet owners. “We (collectively) spent thousands of hours uncompensated talking to aggrieved pet owners just because they needed to talk,” he said. “It was a very tragic situation. Tragic. No amount of money can make certain people whole. There are elderly people who lost a pet who are devastated. I spoke to one who is on antidepressants who won’t get another dog because he doesn’t want to outlive it.”

Click here for larger view

Maitland, a single mother of four, likely represents the feelings of many pet owners when she says she regarded her dog Michigan as family. She adopted him when he was a year old. She was dubious at first about having a dog, but he immediately was so protective of her children — warding off strangers, for example, when the kids were in the car — that Maitland became equally protective of the dog.

Michigan was 13 when melamine wound up in his Ol’ Roy, a private-label food sold by Wal-Mart. She said the first indication that something was wrong was that Michigan lost control of his bowels. By the second night, he was leaking bloody fluids. Maitland and a friend drove Michigan at 1 in the morning to an emergency clinic 35 to 40 minutes away.

“Just walking into the emergency clinic, right on the spot, it was $500,” she recalled. “I had to borrow that money from my friend that was there. I said, ‘We can’t even get home because my car’s on empty.’ They took $25 off (the bill) so we could get home.”

Maitland ended up with about $1,000 in veterinary expenses from two clinics. When she retrieved Michigan after several days of medical care, it was with the thought that he should die at home. But he didn’t, not right away. He actually regained strength, although Maitland said Michigan never fully healed. He died 14 months after the poisoning came to light.

Maitland submitted a claim for $1,072.87. In August, she received a check for $587.

“I don’t feel like I got anything out of this,” she said. “I feel like it was a four-year wait and I think we all got ripped off.”

Like Maitland, Karl Rahder of Naperville, Ill., received a check this summer amounting to about half of his claim, which totaled more than $1,500.

Rahder’s cat, a traditional sealpoint Siamese named Inca, became sick from eating tainted Iams cat food. Rahder, a writer and teacher on international relations and global affairs, recalled that Inca began vomiting and having diarrhea, stopped eating and became listless around February 2007 — several weeks before the recall began.

Her condition “caused me a great deal of worry,” Rahder said in an interview by email. “I was afraid she was going to starve to death or die from renal failure of some kind. A quick check of various Internet forums revealed that a large number of people were experiencing exactly the same thing and were beginning to panic.”

By the time U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) investigators determined the source of the problem, Inca’s health had deteriorated sharply. She spent four or five days in the hospital “close to death,” Rahder recounted. Inca recovered but has never been the same. “Since then, she has been weaker and more fragile,” Rahder said.

His share of the court settlement arrived this summer. He called the payment “quite welcome” if not entirely gratifying.

“It’s hard to say how satisfied we were with the outcome, considering that the payment was reduced by over half and that it took so long for the issue to be resolved,” he mused. “The larger issues, including toxic additives in pet food and a lack of government oversight, certainly trouble me.”

Since the incident, the FDA has taken steps to more closely monitor pet-food safety. In August, the agency announced the establishment of a Pet Event Tracking Network. PETNet, as it’s nicknamed, is a secure, web-based system by which federal, state and territorial agencies can share information about incidents involving pet food, such as illnesses associated with consumption.

For those who lost animals to the melamine scandal, of course, no reforms or compensation will bring back the pets.

More than half of claims involved animals that were fatally poisoned: 13,242 claimants indicated that their pets died. Another 9,001 indicated that their pets were sick but survived; 1,801 indicated that they took their pets for testing after learning about the recall but the pets did not become sick; and 1,557 claimants did not specify the condition of their pets.

An analyst from the claims administration office noted that the claims likely do not fully represent all the animals that were harmed. “The number of claims received in class actions is usually only a percentage of those parties injured,” he wrote. “Therefore, the number of claims received is probably not the total that were injured.”

Many owners whose pets died felt their animals were irreplaceable, judging from some submissions. According to the analyst, claim submissions — not all of which were approved — totaled more than $569 million. One claim alone was for more than $500 million, “almost all of which represented that claimant’s view about the value of her lost pet,” Savett said.

At the other end of the spectrum, someone submitted a claim for 30 cents. The nature of that claim, as with all the claims, is confidential, Paul said. The median claim was $951.46.

Among approved claims, the largest disbursement was $21,986. The smallest was 33 cents. The median disbursement was $430.

The settlement agreement set limits on payments in certain categories. Payment of eligible but undocumented claims was capped at $900 per claimant. Reimbursements for screening and testing of animals that ate tainted food but proved not to be ill were limited to a total of $400,000. Payments for pet food expenses were limited to $250,000 in aggregate.

According to the claims analyst, most claims fell under the “other economic damages” category. Owing to the number of eligible submissions, those claims were paid at a pro rata share of 52.1 percent. Pet food reimbursement claims were paid pro rata at 49.5 percent. Healthy screening and testing claims were paid at 100 percent. Once all qualified healthy-screening-and-testing claims were satisfied, money remaining in that portion of the fund was applied to qualified claims for other economic damages, Paul said.

Savett said lawyers for the class negotiated liberal claims procedures, such as the allowance of up to $900 in undocumented expenses. Those generous guidelines made more claims eligible for payment, she said — which, overall, ended up reducing the amount of money available for any given claim.

Eble, the class-action expert, said such suits have value beyond the monetary compensation. “They do modify corporate behavior. They do prevent theft,” Eble said. “So many of these cases ... they accomplish a goal to serve a public purpose. You don’t have to worry about getting dog food in the future that is contaminated with melamine because now they know they have to test for it. It’s too expensive not to.”

New Products!

Mycodex - Flea and Tick with 3x's Pytethrin - 12oz $7.99

Newt's Chews

Small - $4.25

Medium - $6.25 

Large - $11.50

Newt’s Chews are an all natural dog chew made from high grade shed deer antler. Rich in calcium and phosphorus, these long lasting dog chews provide the benefits of raw bone without the stains, smells, or risk of splintering.

This is one of the longest lasting chews you will ever buy for your dog (typically lasting 2-4 weeks) and the fact that it is shed antler means you can rest assured that no animals were harmed in the making or collecting of this product.

Every year deer and elk shed their antlers to make way for the re-growth of new ones. This renewable resource is rich in minerals and free of inorganic materials such as plastic polymers and chemical materials that make up most commercial dog chews.

Newt’s Chews are sold in three sizes: small, medium, and large. Compared to other companies, our generous sizes are an incredible value! We recognize that multiple dog households contain small and large dogs alike, therefore our “small” size is considered “large” enough to considered safe around large breed dogs.

6" E and F Bully Sticks - $2.55 per
12" E and F Bully Sticks - $3.60

Great for chewers and keeping your favorite dogs teeth free from tarter buildup!

Reflections of Sharon Donates 10% to GRRSN

Bring the Beauty of the Sea to Your Front Door

To view the entire shop click here

This stunningly beautiful 12" seashell wreath, is graced with vibrant silk flowers, natural moss, scallops and a starfish. It is all tied together with a matching gossamer bow and a simple fisherman's net.

Cat Shedding Too Much?

Do you get tired of all that cat hair?  Why not bring them in for a shave.  Call today to book an appointment at (702) 349-9214.

Robert the ultimate shedding machine!

Robert after the shave

You can call me Rob now!

Perfect Kibble for Senior/Overweight Dogs

Canidae Dry Dog Food for Senior and Overweight Dogs, Platinum Formula, 30 Pound Bag

Canidae Dry Dog Food for Senior and Overweight Dogs, Platinum Formula, 30 Pound Bag

• Now with More Meat and Reduced Level of Overall Carbohydrates
• All Natural, Human Grade, Holistic Pet Food
• Four Human Grade Meat Meals: Chicken, Turkey, Lamb, and Fish

Canidae Platinum Formula for Seniors and Overweight Dogs Dry Dog Food is made with all natural dog food formula made with four human grade meat meals with reduced fat and protein. Dogs Love the Taste of Canidae Platinum Formula for Seniors and Overweight Dogs Dry Dog Food. It is made with an all-natural formula with lower protein, lower fat and reduced calories. Also made with glucosamine and chondroitin to promote better joint health and psyllium for fiber intake to help with digestion.

Canidae Rewards Program

Next time you pick up a bag of Canidae from Nala's ask about our rewards program.  Buy 12 bags and the next one is free!  That is up to a $51.00 savings!

Do You Have A Fat Cat?

Fat Pat

These pictures were taken approximately five years apart.  Cats will loose about 1/4 pound per month.  So in a years time you should expect to take about only three pounds off your favorite kitty.

Fatty Patty went from 28#'s to 15#'s, in another words, she lost an entire cat!

She is much happier now, how do I know?  Well she no longer makes us bleed!  She was such a  grouch when she was obese.  I know she feels much better now.

If you have an overweight cat, no more free feeding.  No more dry food.  Feed your cat 3oz of a quality canned food in the morning and 3oz canned food in the evening.   I like BFF, it is a grain free formula and cats seem to love it.

With your help, your cat should live a longer and healthier life.

Patty

Thin Pat

Amazon Donates to Golden Rescue

Shop here for all your Amazon products and around 6% will be donated back on each purchase to GRRSN.  www.grrsn.org a non-profit Golden Retriever rescue organization placing great dogs into new homes!

Bruce

Rainbow Bridge Wreath

Click here to purchase

Click on picture to enlarge

This very special "Rainbow Bridge" wreath says it all... Memorialize your favorite pet and all that they meant to you and your family.
Included with the wreath is "The Rainbow Bridge Poem".
This one of a kind wreath would also make a loving gift for the grieving pet lover in your life.

Just this side of heaven is a place called Rainbow Bridge.

When an animal dies that has been especially close to someone here, that pet goes to Rainbow Bridge. There are meadows and hills for all of our special friends so they can run and play together. There is plenty of food, water and sunshine, and our friends are warm and comfortable.
All the animals who had been ill and old are restored to health and vigor. Those who were hurt or maimed are made whole and strong again, just as we remember them in our dreams of days and times gone by. The animals are happy and content, except for one small thing; they each miss someone very special to them, who had to be left behind.

They all run and play together, but the day comes when one suddenly stops and looks into the distance. His bright eyes are intent. His eager body quivers. Suddenly he begins to run from the group, flying over the green grass, his legs carrying him faster and faster.

You have been spotted, and when you and your special friend finally meet, you cling together in joyous reunion, never to be parted again. The happy kisses rain upon your face; your hands again caress the beloved head, and you look once more into the trusting eyes of your pet, so long gone from your life but never absent from your heart.